Caithesan v. Amjad, 2016 ONSC 5720
In this case the Plaintiffs brought motions for summary judgment against the Defendant, Saad Amjad (Amjad) who was 16 years old at the time of the incident. He had taken his mother’s car without consent and then lost control of the car injuring two of his passengers. Based on his conduct, his mother’s insurer took an off-coverage position. As a result, the two Plaintiffs each brought claims against their own insurers. The claims were settled and then each insurance company crossclaimed against Amjad for the settlement amounts. Both Plaintiffs brought a motion for summary judgment.